By Our Correspondent
NEW DELHI/ BHUBANESWAR: Union Minister for HRD Ramesh Pokhariyal ‘Nishank’ and UGC Chairman, Prof DP Singh Seems Keeps Blind Eye to Bhubaneswar based, KIIT University’s Fraudulent ‘Institute of Eminence’ Status.
Pokhariyal on Friday reviewed meeting in New Delhi on the progress of works sanctioned under the Institute of Eminence Scheme (IoE) in New Delhi. MoS for HRD Sanjay Dhotre co-chaired the meeting . Amit Khare, Secretary HE and Chandra Sekhar, JS (IOE) were also present in the meeting. Bureau Heads of MHRD, Various Directors of different institutions and Vice Chancellors of various IOEs were also present through Video Conferencing.
During the meeting the Minister said that a Project Management Unit should be established in MHRD for monitoring the works of the IOEs and HEFA in 15 days. Nishank assured that a commitment letter from MHRD will be issued to various public institutions of IoEs that funds will be released for expenditure done as per the MOU of IoE. He also desired that construction activities have been open now and work may be expedited in IoEs which have stopped due to Covid-19.
Nishank said that a vision document of three years may be prepared by each institute and sent to MHRD for compilation. He added that the work-related to research and innovations being done in various institutions can be obtained from various institutes and should be uploaded on YUKTI portal for wider publicity and dissemination.The issues related to draft MOU and the inspection of private institutions were also discussed during the meeting.
The ongoing probe by the University Grant Commission basing on Media reports on ‘Institution of Eminence’ status given to Bhubaneswar, Odisha based, KIIT deemed to be University, founded and run by the ruling BJD’s Lok Sabha MP from tribal dominated, religious conversion hit southern district of Odisha’s Kandhamal , Dr Achyuta Samanta despite lacking adequate merit for the status, has not figure in the meeting.
The www.indianewsdiary.com, is the only media house from Odisha , has been following this development after the New Delhi based leading English Daily, ‘The Indian Express’ exposed a massive irregularities in awarding IeO to Bhubaneswar based KIIT and VIT, Chennai, Tamil Nadu.
Soon after the media reports in New Delhi, The www.indianewsdiary.com had sent an email questionnaire to both UGC Chairman Prof DP Singh and Union HRD Minister Ramesh Pokhaial’s Office seeking for their reply, which was not yet responded.
The office of Prof DP Singh, Chairman,UGC had earlier informed over phone from New Delhi that it had received the email sent to it by the News Website and had started a probe into the Institution of Eminence (IoE) status given to Bhubaneswar, Odisha based KIIT deemed to be University, despite lacking adequate merit for the status.
Talking over phone from New Delhi, officials manning the office of UGC Chairman Prof Singh, however had informed that since the matter was related to ‘Institution of Eminence’, they had forwarded the mail to the concerned wing of UGC to take necessary action. He had then informed that Prof Tripathy of UGC had been asked to look into it and an email reply will be sent in detail to the News Website The www.indianewsdiary.com, but nothing has happened in last 4 months.
Earlier, officials manning the office of UGC Chairman had however sought written questions to comply with answers. As per the demand, www.indianewsdiary.com, had sent questions to Union HRD Minister’s office as well as office of UGC chairman Prof DP Singh to sent their reactions, written of reply of which are awaited. The www.indianewsdiary.com has been following all illegal work of KIIT and two of its sister concerns, KIMS and KISS since CBI registered cases over MCI approval for MBBS admission in KIMS.
Here are questions put for UGC Chiarman, Prof DP Singh to reply
A-As to Why UGC granted Institute of Excellence Status in August, 2019, despite KIIT lacking the basic criteria set by the Union HRD Ministry.
B-What action has been taken so far against KIIT University by UGC after the HRD Ministry Notice.
C-Knowing well that Dr Samant, the founder of KIIT, was earlier caught by CBI, for fraudulent means for MCI approval for his KIMS and Dr Samanta himself was a former Member of UGC, how UGC granted the status.
D-What will be the next move of the UGC on KIIT.
Besides, UGC, www.indianewsdiary.com had sent an email putting 4 questions to answer by the office of Union HRD Minister Ramesh Pokhrial. Questioners have been sent to B V R C Purushottam, Private Secretary to Union HRD Minister.
Here are questions put for Union HRD Minister’s office reply.
1. As to Why UGC granted Institute of Excellence Status in August,
2019, despite KIIT lacking the basic criteria set by the Union HRD
Ministry.
2. What action has been taken so far against UGC, KIIT University by the HRD Ministry
3. Knowing well that Dr Samant, the founder of KIIT, was earlier caught by CBI, for fraudulent means for MCI approval for his KIMS and
Dr Samanta himself was a former Member of UGC, how UGC granted the status
4. What will be the next move of the HRD Ministry
The HRD Ministry had reportedly asked UGC to reply as to why ‘Institution of Eminence’ Status given to Bhubaneswar based KIIT deemed to be University, founded by BJD Lok Sabha MP Dr Samanta despite lacking adequate merit for the status. The scheme first ran into controversy in July 2018, with the selection of Reliance Foundation’s non-existent Jio Institute among India’s first six IoEs (three public and three private). KIIT officials said it is a Government matter. PR department officials of KIIT not responded to this.
Media reports says, according to the UGC’s regulations on the IoE scheme, the sponsoring organisation is a “charitable or a not-for-profit Society or a public Trust or a Company incorporated under Section 8 of the Companies Act, 2013” applying to upgrade an existing private institution or a new one to an IoE.The eligibility criterion states the collective net worth of the members of the sponsoring organisation should be Rs 3,000 crore for existing institutions and Rs 5,000 crore for new ones.
The IoE scheme, a brain child of the Prime Minister’s Office and special move of Prime Minister Narendra Modi , which was launched under the NDA-II Government, is aimed at creating an enabling architecture for 10 public and 10 private institutes to emerge as world-class institutions.
The IoEs are proposed to have greater autonomy, including on deciding the fee, and course duration and structure. Their academic collaboration with foreign institutions will also be exempt from approvals. The 10 government institutions, in addition to autonomy, will get Rs 1,000 crore each from the HRD Ministry.
However, the application KIIT show that both have provided the market value of current assets, such as land and building, as the net worth of the sponsoring organisation.The above eligibility clause was at the source of a lot of heartburn among many private higher education institutions as it had left them out of the application process.
Dr Samanta and his KIIT had earlier came under scanner of CBI for faking documents, man power and infrastructure support to get MCI approval for MBBS admission in KIMS 10 years back, now with HRD Ministry asking UGC, in which Dr Samanta had earlier as a Member before being elected a Lok Sabha MP from Odisha’s Kandhamal in last 2019 Parliamentary polls.
Sources said, after media reports, particularly, several reports that published in New Delhi based ‘The Indian Express’, HRD Ministry took serious note of another major scam of KIIT University and has sought an explanation from UGC on whether the KIIT University in Bhubaneswar in Odisha and Vellore Institute of Technology in Tamil Nadu are eligible for the ‘Institution of Eminence’ (IoE) status.On August 2, 2019, UGC had declared KIIT and VITas IoEs despite not meeting the eligibility criterion on the net worth of the sponsoring organisation members.
N Gopalaswami, Head of the expert committee that recommended names of institutes for IoE status, told to The Indian Express , “As EEC (Empowered Expert Committee), we are not involved in this (checking eligibility). It was the government which sent us the names in the first instance (stating) that these (institutions) are fulfilling the (eligibility) criteria. We were given a list of institutions that fulfil the criteria and we were to make a selection out of that. Our position is very clear.”“If in forwarding (the list) to us, there has been some lacunae, it’s for them (UGC and Ministry) to look at it and take a view on what is to be done,” he said.
KIIT’s application pegs the net worth of its four-member sponsoring organisation, KIIT Society, at Rs 10,000 crore. “The society is a non-profit organisation. The net-worth of individual members of the society do not contribute towards financing the Deemed to be university. Net worth of the organisation is around (Rs) 10,000 crores,” the application, said according to The Indian Express report. It then lists the value of KIIT Society’s cash in hand, bank balance, investment in fixed deposits, loans and advances, land and building, among other things, in the net worth statement.
It may be noted here that near about 7 years back, CBI had came to know about KIIT empire’s illegal business but off late , CBI had registered a case against sitting BJD Lok Sabha MP from Kandhamal Dr Achyut Samant. But nothing has happened yet.
Dr Samant was at that time Member of University Grant Commission, as a result of which, Medical Council of India had derecognised its MBBS course for two years in KIIT University run Kalinga Institute of Medical Science(KIMS).MCI had debarred the KIMS in Bhubaneswar from running MBBS course for year 2012-13 and 2012-14 because of the allegations levelled against the Institute by the CBI.The CBI had charged KIMS officials, including its then principal Bhagabati Charan Das, of party to a massive forgery to give an impression – at least on documents – that the Institute met the criteria for running an MBBS programme in 2010.
KIIT and KIMS had paid hefty amount to the medicos to masquerade as KIMS doctors. CBI had charge sheeted KIMS Dean Cum Principal BC Das, Secretary Dr Samant, APO Debasish Debata and Deputy CEO Dilip Kumar Panda. Cases were registered under sections 120(B), 420(Cheating), 468(Forgery for purpose of cheating), 471(using forged documents as genuine) and 176 of IPC
KIMS is affiliated to the Kalinga Institute of Industrial Technology University (KIIT), which was founded by Dr Samanta. The CBI had also chargesheeted Samanta, accusing him of cheating and forgery.After the CBI case, the Naveen Patnaik Government had suspended seven doctors for faking as employees of KIMS to save it from MCI de-recognition.
The suspended doctors were suspended at that time including Bablu Tudu(posted at Badampahad in Mayurbhanj, JP Behera(Bhawanipatna District Headquarters’ Hospitals), AS Pal(Madhupur, Kalahandi, Manoranjan Panigrahi(Police Hospital, Bhawanipatna), Jagannath Hansda(Gadia, Mayurbhanj), JR Pradhan(Rangamatia, Mayurbhanj and Sanjay Kumar Sahoo(Muribahal in Balangir) under the Odisha Civil Services(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules , 1962.
Under scanner former Supreme Court judge, Justice IM Quddusi during his term with Odisha High Court downplayed several cases against Dr Achyut Samanta led KIIT and KIMS. Many writ petitions from Dr Achyuta led organizations are allowed which has raised millions of questions.Justice Quddui;s son Raghat Quddusi’s love.com film was shooting in different places of KIIT and Kalinga group of institutions few years back.
A RTI activist demanded the review of all the judgements declared during Qudussi’s time in Achyuta Samanta related matters. He added, ‘transparency is key to justice. After arrest of Justice Quddusi by CBI on graft charges, his verdicts now are suspected’. Leading RTI activists have said, ‘the allegation is serious. they have been questioning illegality of Dr Samanta since past several years.
It is to be noted that information revealed through RTI that Dr Samanta led organizations run without approval from environmental authority. Further, National Green Tribunal(NGT) had directed to restore the pristine conditions of forest which is under illegal possession of his organizations.
